A business can be doing many things better than it was three years ago — and still find growth challenging to achieve.
Stronger teams. Better systems. More experienced management. Improved processes.
These improvements matter. But they don't necessarily mean the business is better positioned to deliver growth.
And when growth begins to slow, action is needed, but caution is also necessary.
So what, exactly, needs to change?
Slower percentage growth isn't necessarily evidence of a problem. As a business becomes larger, a lower growth rate may still represent a greater increase in revenue.
Equally, improvements in efficiency don't always translate into greater effectiveness. Streamlining service delivery may reduce costs, for example, but if customer satisfaction or retention deteriorates, the commercial consequences may outweigh the savings.
Before deciding how to respond, leadership teams need to understand what's driving performance.
An attractive market opportunity may still exist, but the business may be losing ground to competitors.
A new strategy may be sound but need more time, investment or organisational capability to deliver.
Changing direction in those circumstances risks abandoning an opportunity before it has been properly tested or before the business has strengthened its competitive advantage in ways that matter to customers.
Of course, markets do mature. Customer priorities shift and competitors adapt. Technology, regulation and economic pressures can alter the attractiveness of an opportunity, sometimes remarkably quickly.
In those circumstances, businesses can continue investing in the same markets, pursuing the same customers and improving the delivery of plans built on assumptions that are no longer as reliable as they once were.
In this case, the danger is becoming better at executing a strategy that is becoming less relevant to the market.
The leadership challenge is knowing when to improve execution, when to adapt and when to fundamentally reconsider the strategy.
And that requires more than looking at whether revenue is ahead of or behind plan.
Revenue growth tells us what has happened. It doesn't necessarily tell us why, or whether the conditions supporting future growth remain attractive.
A business may be meeting its revenue target while becoming increasingly dependent on a small number of customers, accepting lower margins or relying on opportunities that are becoming harder to replace.
Equally, disappointing revenue performance may conceal strengthening customer retention, an improving pipeline in priority segments or a proposition that is beginning to gain traction.
Neither position should automatically trigger a strategic change.
The metrics reaching the leadership team need to distinguish between market opportunity, competitive position and execution performance.
Most businesses measure progress against their plans. But how effectively do they measure whether the assumptions underpinning those plans remain valid?
Are priority markets and customer segments still growing? Is the business strengthening or losing its competitive position? Are customer needs, buying behaviours or competitive alternatives changing?
And are the chosen strategies delivering the expected commercial returns — or are the problems primarily related to conversion, capacity, capability or execution?
These are different questions, requiring different evidence.
Without that distinction, leadership teams risk making strategic decisions in response to performance measures that don't explain the underlying problem.
Three actions to take now:
-
Revisit the assumptions behind your growth strategy. Identify the market, customer, competitive and economic conditions on which your plans depend. What evidence tells you those assumptions remain valid, and what has materially changed?
-
Separate strategic indicators from execution measures. Review changes in market demand, segment attractiveness, competitive position and customer behaviour alongside conversion, margins, retention, pipeline and delivery performance. Are these measures helping you distinguish a weakening opportunity from underperformance within an attractive one?
-
Establish what would justify changing direction. Identify which signals warrant adapting the strategy, which require improvements in execution, and which may be short-term fluctuations. Agree what evidence is needed before reallocating significant resources or abandoning an existing growth priority.
The question isn't whether businesses should keep changing their strategy in response to the latest market development.
Nor is it whether they should remain committed to a plan simply because it has worked before.
It's whether leadership has the evidence and judgement to know when to stay the course — and when the market is telling them something needs to change.
